An Important Feature of the Permanent Way
TRACK TOPICS - 5
AN EXPRESS OF THE LNER is seen running at speed, headed by “Pacific” locomotive No. 2543 “Melton”. In the foreground is seen a “single slip” - a diamond crossing of two tracks with slip connexion between them.
BY far the most costly part of the permanent way to construct and to keep in repair is the switch and crossing work. In the chapter, “The Permanent Way”, attention is given to railway track in general, and to the problems which face the permanent-way engineer. The complexities of junction lay-out work and connexions between one track and another require separate consideration.
In the above chapter emphasis is laid on the punishment to which railway track is subjected as the heavy weight of locomotives, coaches, and wagons rolls over it, sometimes at very high speeds. To the line-side observer this may not be so apparent as to those immediately concerned with maintenance problems; but even the uninitiated, as they hear an express thundering over a junction, must realize by the sound alone that the track at such points as these is being subjected to enormous stresses. They are at their maximum where one track crosses another, and the wheels have to bridge the gap in the rail which is necessarily left, so that the flanges of wheels using the other track may pass through.
First of all it is necessary to study the details of an ordinary “turn-out” - that is, a set of points or switches, and the crossing that is needed to enable the outer rail of the diverging track to cross the inner rail of the straight track. A typical cross-over, a picture of which appears below, is that at Theydon Bois Station, Essex.
The essentials of a switch are two “tongue-rails”, tapering at the extreme end down to a knife-edge, and tied firmly together by two or three transverse “stretcher-bars”. Ordinary rails are used to make the tongues, and in special planing machines, generally two to four at a time, the heads are planed down at a very acute angle until the thickness of the head at the pointed end is reduced practically to zero. A certain amount has also to be planed off the foot so that the whole tongue, when in the closed position, may house firmly against the solid rail behind it. The latter is known as the “stock-rail”, and each switch thus requires two stock-rails on the outside, and two tongue-rails in the centre. The care with which the tongues must be designed and their planing carried out may be measured from the fact that they have smoothly to divert the wheel-flanges from their straight path. At the same time they have to divert the entire weight of the locomotives and rolling stock resting on the wheels, when the train, perhaps, is travelling very fast.
A variant of the knife-edge type of tongue, largely in use on the Great Western Railway and to a lesser extent on other lines, is obtained by setting the stock-rail back three-eighths of an inch, exactly opposite the point of the tongue, so that the latter may be planed down to a point three-eighths of an inch thick, instead of to a knife-edge. This has a considerable advantage in giving the tongue a longer life, as it does not wear away or suffer damage so readily as a knife-edge tongue, but there are also certain disadvantages to be faced.
A reverse bend, or “joggle”, has to be made in the stock-rail, within a length of no more than four to six inches, to form the recess that houses the thick tongue, and this recess runs out into the straight again at a point opposite the end of the planing. The result, when the tongue is open, and the stock-rail exposed, is not merely to make the latter look out of straight, but also to leave a slightly projecting angle in the running edge of the rail. This may cause rough riding to trains coming through the switch in a trailing direction, and is inclined to wear down with undue rapidity for the same reason. It would, however, take considerably more space than a single paragraph adequately to argue the relative merits of “straight-cut” (joggled) and “under-cut” (ordinary) switches.
A CROSS-OVER ROAD at Theydon Bois, Essex, on the LNER. Each cross-over road requires
two sets of switches and two common or acute rail crossings. Cross-overs are generally laid
“trailing”, as are also siding connexions, in order to reduce to a minimum the number of facing
switches in the running lines.
The lateral movement of the tongue, from the closed to the open position, is usually from four to five inches. A special type of chair, known as a “slide chair”, is used throughout the movable part of the switch. That is to say, a chair with a jaw on one side only, to which the stock-rail is bolted. The other side consists of a flat seat, kept well oiled, on which the tongue-rail slides. At the back end of the switch, beyond the movable portion, both rails are securely keyed in double chairs, known as “heel chairs”. There is sufficient spring in the tongue-rail to permit of its movement to and fro with the “heel” as a pivotal point, and it is only in short switches, where excessive spring would be needed, that a joint is made in the tongue-rail at the heel.
The heel is the point at which the gap between the stock-rail and the tongue-rail has increased to one and three-quarter inches; and from the heel to the point of the tongue is the effective length of the switch. Between the heel and the point where the planing begins, the stock-rail chairs are provided with special studs which project sufficiently into the web of the tongue to provide a firm bearing for the latter throughout its length - partly in the heel chairs, partly against the studs, and partly by contact with the stock-rail along the length of the planing. This is extremely important, because the flanges of the wheels exert a strong outward thrust as they are diverted from their straight path by the tongue, and were it not thus held rigid throughout they might force the tongue out of gauge, and cause a derailment.
Connecting the two tongues together, so that they move in unison, are the stretcher-bars, now usually cut from a length of rectangular spring steel, which is set up on edge, and joined to the rails by forged steel clips. To the outermost of these bars - that is, the one nearest the point of the switch - is attached the “pull-rod” by which the switch is moved, either by rodding from the signal cabin, or, in sidings, by an adjacent hand lever.
It is vitally important that the switch tongue, when in the closed position, shall have moved fully home, as any projection of the tongue away from the stock-rail might easily cause a derailment. This is where electricity plays its part. In all switches in “running roads” - that is, lines over which through traffic is moved, as opposed to sidings - electrical “detectors” are fixed. These can tell, almost down to the thickness of a piece of paper, if the tongue is properly in contact with the stock-rail. If not, electrical locking prevents the moving of the signal-arm, which will permit a train to travel over the switch.
Another important precaution is that of preventing the movement by a signal-man of a switch while a train is running over it in the “facing” direction - that is, travelling from the point towards the heel, and not from the heel to the point, which is “trailing”. The principal risk in this connexion is that of the long bogie coach, in which the distance between the bogies is such that it would be possible without interference to move a switch between the passage of the front and rear bogies
of the same coach. In consequence, the front bogie would take one track, and the rear bogie the other, and a disastrous
derailment would result.
At important facing switches in running roads “locking-bars” are now therefore provided. They consist of a length of light “T” or “Γ” section, usually 40 ft, carried on hinged arms which are bracketed at the side of the rail. The locking-bar, connected to a plunger device which is usually fixed down in the middle of the track, normally lies horizontally, either on the inside or the outside of the rail immediately adjacent to the switch, and just below rail level. In this position the switch is “locked”, and no amount of effort on the part of the signalman can move it.
When a switch movement has to be made, the switch must first be unlocked. By pulling over the appropriate lever the signalman causes the rocker-arms of the locking-bar to move through an arc, thus lifting the flat bar momentarily above rail level, and then dropping it again. The switch is now unlocked and can be moved. But before the appropriate signal can be moved to “clear”, the facing-point lock plunger sees to it that the switch must be re-locked, which means putting the locking-bar lever back into the frame, and so moving the locking-bar itself back through the same arc as before.
IN OLD OAK COMMON YARD on the Great Western Railway, near Paddington. To the right of the cabin is a single slip connexion, and behind that a single-tongue trap.
Now the rising of the locking-bar above rail-level means that the operation of unlocking and relocking cannot be accomplished when any vehicles are standing on or moving over the track immediately adjacent to the switch. The 40-ft length of the locking-bar is greater than the maximum distance between any two pairs of wheels of the longest coaches in use. This simple precaution thus prevents any movement of a switch equipped with a locking-bar when a train is travelling over it or standing on it. Locking-bars are fixed either on the tongues of a switch, or, more generally, on the stock-rails adjacent to the switch. Several can clearly be seen in the photograph of movable diamond crossings shown below.
Fouling bars are somewhat similar in construction, but serve a different purpose. They are of the same length, but are carried on spring brackets, and at such a height that they are depressed on their springs when a train is standing on or moving over them. When depressed, the bar completes an electric circuit, and the occupation of this section of line is thus electrically notified in the signal-box concerned. They may often be seen in the platforms of terminal stations, and are designed to prevent a signalman from making mistakes owing to forgetfulness that a section of track out of sight of his box
Reverting for a moment to switches, provided there is ample room available, the length of a switch is governed by the speeds which are to be run over the diverging line. The higher the speed, the longer the switch; and the longest switches are those laid in at junctions between two main lines, where more or less equal speeds are desired over either track. The chief difficulty is that of arranging for the necessary super-elevation, or “cant”, of the diverging line. A clever solution of the
Problem - which would occupy too much space for detailed description - has recently been reached, however, jointly by the Engineering Department of the LMS and Messrs. Taylor Bros. (Sandiacre), Ltd, the well-known manufacturers of permanent-way lay-outs, and will provide for properly super-elevated junctions safely permitting speeds of sixty to seventy miles per hour over either track. The value of this development in these days of high-speed travel needs no stress.
As less in the matter of precautionary measures is needed with a trailing than with a facing switch, in running roads trailing switches are laid in wherever possible. Cross-over roads between the two tracks of an ordinary double line, for example, such as that illustrated at Theydon Bois Station, are invariably laid trailing. Connexions from sidings, such as the one seen beyond the right-hand platform in the same photograph, are also laid to trail, except in the case of “reception roads”, which are entered through facing points, and left through trailing points. The advantage of the reception road, as compared with an ordinary siding, is that the time spent in stopping a long and heavy freight train, and setting back into a siding, is completely eliminated by the train passing direct into the siding through facing points, and there is a correspondingly quicker clearance of the main line.
A STRIKING YARD LAY-OUT at Winnipeg, on the Canadian Pacific Railway. In the distance is seen the “hump” at the entrance to the yard, over which the trains are slowly pushed, the uncoupled wagons being run by gravity into their appropriate sidings.
In the past, three-throw switches, giving simultaneous divergence both to the left and right through one switch, were used to some extent in sidings, and have some advantage in the matter of compactness. But they are troublesome to maintain, because of the thinness of the inner set of tongues, and the general complexity of construction as compared with a pair of ordinary switches. Given adequate space, the permanent-way engineer will use two independent switches instead.
Another type of switch which may have puzzled some readers is a single tongue, set in one side only of a straight track -that is, half a switch, and leading, in effect, to nowhere. It is deliberately designed as a trap. Where a station, for example, is located on an incline, there is the risk that, while shunting, wagons might start to run away down the “wrong line”, and if they met a train proceeding in the opposite direction, the result would be disastrous. The trap would, however, throw the vehicles off the road in time, and by the lesser casualty the greater would be avoided. Trap points are generally arranged to work against a spring, so that trains travelling over the trap in the right direction force the tongue to close, after which it again springs open automatically. A single-tongue trap can be seen in the photograph of Old Oak Marshalling Yard of the Great Western Railway.
RELAYING A “SCISSORS CROSSING”. This unit of track, weighing 25 tons, and 100 ft in length, has been assembled at the side of the main line, and is being moved into position on ball-bearing rollers. It consists of a double cross-over road, and the complications of the centre crossing construction is clearly seen.
Proceeding from the heel of the switch, the outer rail of the diverging line has next to cross the inner rail of the straight line. A rail crossing of this description is known as a “common” or an “acute” crossing. Study of the photographs reproduced in this chapter will show how both running rails are bent outwards to form “wings”, enclosing the “nose” of the crossing, which
consists of two rails secured together, and planed down to a sharp point or nose. It is the straight rail, known as the “point-rail”, which is planed down to the nose. The rail of the diverging track is slightly bent and twisted, and then planed head and foot in such a way that it can be firmly bolted to the side of the point rail, with the two webs touching. Between the point and splice-rails and the two wings gaps or flange-ways must be left wide enough to receive the flanges of the wheels as they pass through, the customary space being 1⅝ inches.
Strong double chairs hold the rails through the crossing, and from the nose to the end of the wings each crossing chair, which is of considerable length, must hold four rails. In addition, cast iron blocks, accurately shaped, are fitted between the wings and the point and splice-rails, with bolts running right through from one side of the crossing to the other. Their purpose is both to prevent the point from moving longitudinally in relation to the wings (which might either close up or open out the flange-way gaps), and also to keep the rails at precisely the right distance from one another, as on the preservation of this distance smooth running through the crossing largely depends.
A SIDE VIEW of the movable diamond crossings at Old Oak Common.
The nose chair of the modern crossing is of a built-up type, with separate steel base, cast iron side-brackets and centre blocks, a transverse bolt holding the components together (by passing through brackets, blocks and rails), and five holding-down bolts, two securing each bracket through the steel base to the sleeper, and a further one holding down the nose of the point-rail. This type of construction allows of the nose of the crossing being kept in constantly tight adjustment. Additional protection against derailment is obtained by fixing short “check-rails”, 13 feet in length, adjacent to the outer rails of each track opposite the crossing. The check rails are held in ordinary check-chairs, which preserve the standard 1⅝-inch flange-way gap between the check and the running
Standard common crossings are made in all angles from 1 in 4 up to 1 in 12, together with half-angles, such as 1 in 8½ or 1 in 10½. This variety of angles entails the stocking of an enormous variety of crossing chairs, as each angle must have its own set of chairs and blocks, distinctively marked. For special work more acute and more obtuse angles are made at times, culminating in right-angled crossings of one track over another. But the last-mentioned are avoided if possible, as they involve special design and manufacture. They are costly to maintain in good running order, and cause rough riding to rolling stock.
MOVABLE DIAMOND CROSSINGS provide a solid path for the wheels, as shown by the right-hand rail through this crossing at Old Oak Common West Junction. The point-rails of the diamond are arranged to move like switches and are coupled together by the cranks as shown above to make them move in unison. Two are always open when the other two are closed. Locking-bars are placed alongside the running rails to ensure safety.
This leads us to the consideration of complete crossings of one track over another, which are known as “diamond” crossings, from the diamond shape that is enclosed by the four rails. One diamond crossing occurs at every double line railway junction. At the extreme ends of such diamonds two common or acute crossings are needed; but at the centre there are two crossings of a different type, known as “angle” or “obtuse” crossings.
Several diamonds are seen in the photographs reproduced, from which the characteristic form of construction will be noted. There are in each obtuse crossing one wing rail, bent to an obtuse angle, and run over throughout its length; two point-rails on either side of the centre of the crossing, but no splice-rails; and a check rail guarding the outside of the two points, and coming up to the centre of the crossing, or the “knuckle”. Endeavours are made to keep obtuse crossings to a maximum sharpness of 1 in 8 or 1 in 9, as with leads of 1 in 10 and upwards there is the risk of a wheel-flange taking the wrong side of a point, which would cause derailment.
But any such risk can be overcome by the use of movable diamond crossings, which have the advantage of completely closing up the flange-way gaps at the centre of the diamond, thus giving a solid path for the wheels, and greatly increasing the smoothness of running.
A Signal Safeguard
The two point-rails of each diamond are made movable, in the manner of switch tongues, and the four operate in pairs in such a way that one pair of flange-ways is always open when the other is closed, and vice versa. These movable diamonds are interlocked with the signals, in just the same way as the switches, and there is thus no possibility of a signalman signalling a train in such a way as to permit it to pass through the closed side of the diamond. The Great Western and
Southern Railways have specialized in this form of junction construction, an example of which, at Old Oak Common West Junction on the Great Western Railway, figures in the illustrations above. Some use is also made by the Southern Railway of spring common crossings, which, similarly, give a solid path for the wheels through the crossing, but this track detail is more common in America than in Great Britain.
When tracks cross one another at about 1 in 8 or 1 in 9, especially in sidings, it is often desired to make connexion between the one track and the other. To do so with a maximum of economy in rails, the connexion is made within the two end crossings of the diamond. Because of the proximity of the rails at the two centre crossings, some very complicated chairs are required. A diamond crossing of this description with single connexion is known as a “single slip”. If a double connexion
is provided - an even more complicated piece of work - then the item becomes a “double slip”. Examples of slip construction appear in several of the photographs in this chapter.
AMERICAN RAILROAD TRACK built up from flat-bottomed rails is seen to advantage in this picture of the approach to Oakland Pier Terminal of the Southern Pacific Railway at San Francisco. Note the “double slip” connexion to the right of the electric motor-coach in the foreground.
Another complicated form of track construction is the double cross-over road, or “scissors crossing”, from its resemblance in form to this household implement. This is laid where cross-over roads in both directions are needed, but compactness is essential, as, for example, at stations in the centre of long platforms, so that access may be readily obtained to or from one end of the platform when a train is standing at the other. Here again two independent cross-over roads, end to end, will be used if possible, as the complexity of construction, particularly at the centre, makes the scissors crossing a costly item, Another objection is the shortness of many of the rails which must be used in its centre section. An example of a scissors crossing, in course of being laid in the LNER main line at Thirsk, figures in one of the illustrations above.
The title “double cross-over road” may also be applied to the double connexion between two parallel double tracks of a four-track line. A junction of this description comprises four sets of switches, eight common crossings, and four obtuse crossings. It should here be added that the switches at both ends of every cross-over road are linked together in such a way that both are simultaneously operated by one lever in the signal cabin.
Whenever possible, track lay-outs are assembled from standard switches and crossings, but more complex lay-out work requires special planning and construction. In particular, curves in the tracks which have to be connected complicate the use of standard parts. Whereas a great deal of work in cutting and bending rails to fit was formerly done on the site, when replacements were in progress, the more modern and scientific practice is so to plan and assemble the details of a lay-out that it can practically be dropped into position and fishplated up to the adjacent track directly the worn-out track has been dismantled and removed.
One of the most remarkable track lay-out jobs in existence was put together on Cannon Street bridge of the Southern Railway before the extension of electric working into that terminus. It was planned as one vast unit, built and assembled in sections in the contractors’ works at Sandiacre, near Nottingham; dismantled and reassembled in a field at New Cross; and finally, after all traffic into and out of Cannon Street had been temporarily stopped, and the old track on the bridge removed, it was laid in position, as shown in the fine photograph shown in the chapter on Electric Power on the Grand Scale.
It might be thought that the construction of crossing work would be simplified if a solid steel casting could be used for the central parts of the crossing. To some extent cast noses have so been used, but there are objections to the practice. Generally, castings have not the same capacity for resisting wear as the rolled rails from which the crossings are normally assembled, and of which the steel structure has been improved by the work done on it in the course of rolling, as described in the chapter From Iron Ore to Steel Rail. The underlying nature of solid crossings also tends to cause rough riding of rolling stock, especially when such crossings are traversed at speed. Where steel castings are used in crossing work, it is generally in connexion with flat-bottomed and not bull-head railway track.
The most successful use of castings has been in difficult and complicated locations, particularly where tracks cross each other at right-angles, or nearly so, and also in conjunction with the use of alloy steels. Of these the best-known examples in Great Britain are crossings that have been assembled from the high manganese alloy associated chiefly with the names of Hadfields and other firms in the Sheffield area. The most striking and extensive of these crossings is probably the one found at the east end of Newcastle Central Station of the London and North Eastern Railway. Here tracks from the north side of the station, curving sharply round to the southwards to reach the High Level Bridge, cross, almost at right-angles, the main line from Edinburgh into the through portion of the station; the whole of these crossings have been assembled from specially cast manganese steel crossings.
Rails rolled from manganese steel are also used in the manufacture of switches and crossings for locations where the wear is excessively heavy. Another favourite alloy for this purpose is a steel containing 1 per cent of chromium. Heat treatment is also freely employed for the hardening of crossing noses, and rails which have been heat-treated in their entirety by the Sandberg regulated sorbitic process similarly find considerable favour in the building up of lay-outs subject to severe wear conditions.
COMPLICATED TRACK CONSTRUCTION at Llandudno Junction, Wales, on the LMS Railway. From the right of the picture one track bears left and crosses the double line curving to the right almost at a right-angle. Crossings of this description are avoided where possible as they are costly to maintain in good running order.
You can read more on “From Iron Ore to Steel Rail”, “The Permanent Way” and “Welding in Railway Service” on this website.